This Germantown project proves one person’s trash is another’s treasure

The Mary Street Midden Project is collecting history by digging through the garbage.

A gray building, with cars parked on the street in front.

This building on Mary Street was built on top of a 19th century trash dump — aka a midden.

Image via WHAS11

For artist + archaeologist Patrick Donley, the adage, “One person’s trash is another’s treasure” isn’t just a saying, it’s become an avocation.

For the last five years, Donley has been digging through a pile of rubbish buried under a house in the Germantown neighborhood, gleaning bits of history all along the way.

Called the Mary Street Midden Project, Donley plans to turn the building into a museum, once he’s done digging.

Donley purchased the property on Mary Street — located one door down from Phalcha Coffee — in 1995, to house his art studio. He had no idea at the time, however, the treasure trove of artifacts that lay just a few feet below his feet.

Here’s sampling of what Donley has found, buried in the dirt:

  • Ceramic plates
  • Silverware
  • Over 1,000 glass bottles
  • Handguns
  • Children’s toys, including hundreds of porcelain dolls
A shelf filled with glass bottles from the 19th and early 20th century.

Donley has found ~1,000 glass bottles, including those from local bourbon distilleries that still exist today.

Image via WHAS11

Donley estimates that the midden — that’s an old fashioned word for dump — was used for ~50 years, from the 1870s through the early 1920s. Back in those days, the Germantown neighborhood was located on the outskirts of Louisville.

He hasn’t done it all alone, though. Donley had the helping hands — or paws? — of a groundhog named Phyllis who helped to literally uncovered the past. It was Phyllis, in fact, who got the whole project started by kicking up artifacts buried under the basement slab, right as Donley was considering selling the place.

Donley will speak about the project at the Louisville Free Public Library’s Main Branch on Monday, Nov. 4, from 7 to 8 p.m. Register ahead of time to get a seat for the free talk.

If you’d like to support the Mary Street Midden Project, you can donate to Groundhog Archaeology — Donley’s company, named in honor of Phyllis — or at this GoFundMe page.

More from LOUtoday
Get hooked on these spots from March through April.
This Louisville bookstore has been closed for over 20 years, but it lives on in the memories of its erstwhile patrons.
Bookmark this guide for a curated list of events taking place each month that we’re most looking forward to.
These Louisville resources can help you in family history research
Put your money where your community is and help us create a guide to small businesses by submitting your favorite local spots and sharing this page with a friend.
It’s the biggest lineup in the festival’s history
From classical music to new compositions and pop music, Louisville’s Grammy-winning orchestra has a little something for everyone this year.
This Black-owned pharmacy is bringing local care to Russell and beyond.
Move aside pickleball, there’s a new racket sport in town.
Strap on your skates and grab your sweeping brooms, it’s time for the games